Free shipping on orders over $100!
Log in
Cart (
0
)
Home
Popcorn
Candy
Gifts
Our Story
Home
Popcorn
Candy
Gifts
Our Story
Candy-Nostalgia
All Candy
762 Items
Bulk
280 Items
Nostalgia
169 Items
Boxed
58 Items
Pucker Up
51 Items
Fun Stuff
145 Items
Cotton Candy
11 Items
Specialty
12 Items
Sugar Free
26 Items
Vegan
10 Items
Candy
Nostalgia
Page 2 of 4
Sort by:
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically: A-Z
Alphabetically: Z-A
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Date: New to Old
Date: Old to New
Filter by:
All Nostalgia
Chocolate
Easter
Nutty
Pez
Sour
Spicy
Goo Goo Cluster - Peanut Butter
Nostalgia
Goo Goo Cluster - Peanut Butter
$1.95
|
/
Goo Goo Cluster - Pecan
Nostalgia
Goo Goo Cluster - Pecan
$1.95
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Birthday Cake
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Birthday Cake
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Bourbon Pecan Pie
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Bourbon Pecan Pie
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Chicken & Waffles
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Chicken & Waffles
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Key Lime Pie
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Key Lime Pie
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Malted Milkshake
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Malted Milkshake
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Midnight Snack
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Midnight Snack
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Pigs N Taters
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Pigs N Taters
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Raspberry Habanero
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Raspberry Habanero
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Smores
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Smores
$3.50
|
/
Hammonds Bar - Soda Pop
Nostalgia
Hammonds Bar - Soda Pop
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Berry Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Berry Mix
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Fantasy Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Fantasy Mix
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Fruit Combos
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Fruit Combos
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Original Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Original Mix
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Plus Fruit
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Plus Fruit
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Soda Pop
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Soda Pop
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Superfruit Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Superfruit Mix
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Sweet & Sour Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Sweet & Sour Mix
$3.50
|
/
Hi-Chew Tropical Mix
Nostalgia
Hi-Chew Tropical Mix
$3.50
|
/
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape - Awesome Original
Nostalgia
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape - Awesome Original
$2.25
|
/
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape - Sour Blue Raspberry
Nostalgia
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape - Sour Blue Raspberry
$2.25
|
/
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape - Tangy Tropical
Nostalgia
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape - Tangy Tropical
Sold Out
|
/
Idaho Spud
Nostalgia
Idaho Spud
Sold Out
|
/
Jawbreakers 2.25 Inch
Nostalgia
Jawbreakers 2.25 Inch
$2.95
|
/
Jawbreakers Jumbo 3 Inch
Nostalgia
Jawbreakers Jumbo 3 Inch
$9.95
|
/
Lifesavers Rolls
Nostalgia
Lifesavers Rolls
$1.75
|
/
Lifesavers Rolls Butter Rum
Nostalgia
Lifesavers Rolls Butter Rum
$1.75
|
/
Look Bar
Nostalgia
Look Bar
$1.75
|
/
Mallo Cup
Nostalgia
Mallo Cup
Sold Out
|
/
Mega Smarties Roll
Nostalgia
Mega Smarties Roll
$1.95
|
/
Melody Pops
Nostalgia
Melody Pops
$1.25
|
/
Million Dollar Chocolate Bar
Nostalgia
Million Dollar Chocolate Bar
$2.95
|
/
Million Dollar Dark Chocolate Bar
Nostalgia
Million Dollar Dark Chocolate Bar
Sold Out
|
/
Moon Pie - Chocolate
Nostalgia
Moon Pie - Chocolate
$1.50
|
/
Moon Pie - Vanilla
Nostalgia
Moon Pie - Vanilla
Sold Out
|
/
Mountain Bar - Cherry
Nostalgia
Mountain Bar - Cherry
$1.95
|
/
Mountain Bar - Peanut Butter
Nostalgia
Mountain Bar - Peanut Butter
$1.95
|
/
Mountain Bar - Vanilla
Nostalgia
Mountain Bar - Vanilla
$1.95
|
/
Necco Wafers Assorted
Nostalgia
Necco Wafers Assorted
Sold Out
|
/
Necco Wafers Chocolate
Nostalgia
Necco Wafers Chocolate
Sold Out
|
/
Nerds Twist & Mix
Nostalgia
Nerds Twist & Mix
$3.50
|
/
Now and Later Bar
Nostalgia
Now and Later Bar
$1.95
|
/
Payday Bar
Nostalgia
Payday Bar
$1.75
|
/
Pearson's Nut Goodies
Nostalgia
Pearson's Nut Goodies
$1.95
|
/
Pez Dispensers - Animal Crossing
Nostalgia
Pez Dispensers - Animal Crossing
$2.95
|
/
Pez Dispensers - Care Bears
Nostalgia
Pez Dispensers - Care Bears
$2.95
|
/
Previous
1
2
3
4
Next
Search